Side 1: Nightmare Bay - When an underwater photographer is attacked inside a sea cave, she is saved by lifeguard Mitch Buchannon. The account of the attack is misconstrued and overblown by a newspaper reporter, and Mitch and the other Baywatch lifeguards find themselves dealing with a comical yet dangerous situation created by media hype and speculation that there is a "Creature in the Bay." Side 2: River of No Return - Raging rapids match the ocean surf for danger when Mitch heads for California"s rugged Gold Country to investigate the death of his prospector uncle. David Hasselhoff, Pamela Anderson, Erika Eleniak