I"m sure Volume Four is a 4-star book. However, while most photos and descriptions, including the "Look Inside" feature, show the Scribner"s Set in its 5-volume edition with Volume 4 as The Aftermath, you need to contact the seller to verify that the Volume 4 they are selling is The Aftermath and not The Teutonic Collapse. Some Scribner"s sets have The Aftermath as Volume 5 and The Eastern Front as Volume 6. I found out the hard way when I got a copy of Volume 5 that was The Aftermath and a copy of Volume 4 that was not The Aftermath, but rather The Teutonic Collapse, an earlier portion of the series that covered the end of the war.